Letter about ASOS in NMA

NMA published a letter from me this week which understandably had to be edited down to fit the magazine so I thought I would also post my submission in full in case anyone is interested.

ASOS CEO Nick Robertson certainly created a stir with his comments and while the choice of insulting language was certainly a surprise the most surprising thing is still the fact that ASOS spent two years building relationships on a CPA basis and then turned their back on this and retreated back to offline channels.

Towards the end, the affiliate program was so badly managed with commissions slashed and dictatorial terms & conditions being implemented that it was no surprise the program was closed. Affiliates can and will develop an innovative range of ways to promote your company at their own risk but it’s a two way relationship. Work with your affiliates, build up trust and you will be rewarded. Try to dictate to affiliates exactly how and where they can operate and you will come unstuck as ASOS have.

This does not mean that affiliates are free to do what they like however; affiliate marketing is not different from any other marketing channel in that poor management will get poor results. To me it becomes more and more clear that ASOS took their eye off the ball and paid the price but instead of looking inwards and realising what went wrong they have lashed out at the very affiliates who built the business.

I found myself nodding as I read the recent NMA interview with Alex Bogusky. The consumers do own the brand and just as in the user generated content campaigns that Alex talked about you need to just slightly loosen your grip on your marketing to give affiliates the opportunity to show their true potential.

If you want to protect your brand in search engines then register your trademark with them. If you want to provide guidelines then work with your affiliate network to manage your affiliate program effectively but if you expect to control every mention of your brand then you will miss out on the very crux of the channel where affiliates engage with your customers.

There is talk in NMA of affiliate marketing having an image problem and I won’t deny that an affiliate association would be a step forward for all parties involved. Education of merchants to gain a genuine understanding of the model would move things forward as much as a code of conduct.

I find it hard to see a route back into affiliate marketing for ASOS amongst the marketers that I know and with several affiliate networks already publicly stating they don’t want to work with ASOS I think it will be an uphill struggle following these grubby comments

Fraser Edwards
Affiliateblog.co.uk

Thanks to Will Cooper for getting in touch with a genuine interest in finding out more about the affiliate point of view.

Technorati Tags: ,

back me up

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

Trackback Address

Comments

5 comments | Leave your comment | Feed for this Entry

Peter Berry
Mar 22nd, 2007 at 12:40 pm | #

Great post Fraser,

It’s nice to see an official voice fighting the corner of affiliates. I agree that education of merchants is key, and I guess things like get-togethers could prove vital tools for this means. Hopefully other merchants will recognise the ASOS comments as sadly misguided.

Keep up the good work!

Pete
blue barracuda

Kieron
Mar 22nd, 2007 at 2:13 pm | #

Nice one Fraser, good well balanced opinion on the whole debate.

Lee McCoy
Mar 22nd, 2007 at 4:25 pm | #

Hi Mate

Do you have a copy if the “in situ” version I could have a gander at?

Cheers,

Lee

Fraser
Mar 22nd, 2007 at 4:30 pm | #

It’s online here too

http://www.nma.co.uk/Articles/32397/Letters+ASOS+affiliate+failure+comes+from+within+.html

but you might need a subscription to see it all?

Clarke
Mar 22nd, 2007 at 7:44 pm | #

Great over all article submitted Fraser. I think with the edit the removed some keywords “There is talk in NMA of” for example and understandable as I guess they don’t want readers to think that the image problem could in anyway being inflamed by NMA. However you need to look at these things along the line of if you get 90% of your message across then that is clearly better than being ignored or worst still being misrepresented.

Plus it’s certainly a step in the right direction that they are asking for views from key people like yourself who can offer a balanced view without people remarking your just saying that because of this or that.. certainly a move forward as far to often you get the view point of a media hungry self promoting member of a Network how only concern is to make sure they say the right thing for the brands reading even if it’s not what is for the best.

By the way I am not anti-NMA or anything of the sort, I just found in the past it was always people who could afford adverts or promotions in supplements that had there view pointed heard and are talked up as being great at this or that. To me if you take the view of the people that can pay for adverts and not speak to the ones who don’t or can’t, then it’s not as balanced as it could be. That aside I have no plans to comment in any publications until I can afford the PR machine to back it up and make sure I am represented correctly. Think I will stick to blogs from honest sources such as yourself to comment in as then I can always reply to a follow up if they don’t agree ;)

Leave a comment

Comment Guidelines:
You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Off-topic or inappropriate comments will be edited or deleted.

Email addresses will never be published.

UK Blog Roundup Affiliate Code of Conduct

Latest Podcast

Doug Scott - ASAP Ventures - Interview

June 17, 2008 |

doug-small.jpg In this podcast I've been speaking to Doug Scott of ASAP Ventures. I recorded this podcast a couple of weeks ago but it's taken me till now to find time to catch up and get it edited and properly produced. More...
Recent Podcasts

More podcasts

Fraser Edwards About

Fraser Edwards has been involved in affiliate marketing for more than 5 years after starting out in business as a website developer.

Recent comments